A California woman alleges in a proposed class action that GreenPan maker The Cookware Company (USA) LLC has made false claims with regard to its patented non-stick cookware products.
Although the company has reportedly advertised GreenPan cookware as “Healthy Ceramic Non-Stick,” “Completely Toxin Free,” “good for the environment,” “reinforced…with diamonds,” and containing “No PFOA, PFAS, Lead or Cadmium,” the case claims these statements are false and misleading.
The lawsuit first cuts into the defendant’s “healthy” claims, arguing that GreenPan products are no more “healthy” than any other cookware product and allow customers to prepare both healthy and unhealthy meals. As the complaint puts it:
“While GreenPan’s Products may assist GreenPan’s consumers in preparing ‘healthy’ (as well as non-healthy) meals, GreenPan’s nonstick Products are not, in and of themselves, healthy, nor do they guarantee that the meals cooked in them will be ‘healthy.’”
With regard to GreenPan’s “toxin free” claims, the lawsuit alleges that this assertion is simply not true, as the company’s patented “Thermalon” coating on the products contains known toxins such as silane, aluminum oxide, tetraethoxysilane, methyltrimethoxysilane, and potassium titanate.
Similarly, the suit claims the defendant’s GreenPan products are not “reinforced” with diamonds, “nor do they contain material amounts of diamonds or diamond fragments,” as the products’ packaging represents.
Sticking to the defendant’s “good for the environment” claims, the lawsuit alleges that GreenPan products do not provide any “specific benefit” to the environment that outweighs the negative effects.
“Insofar as GreenPan has qualified this claim with a specific benefit, which Plaintiff argues it has not, upon information and belief, the benefit of ‘not requir[ing] the use of toxic chemicals like PFOA or PFAS during the production process’ is a small and/or unimportant benefit in light of the negative environmental effects GreenPan’s Products create,” the complaint states. “For example, GreenPan’s Products are made of metal and do not, upon information and belief, biodegrade.”
The plaintiff further points out that no non-stick cookware made since 2013 contains perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) or perfluoroalkyls (PFAs), despite The Cookware Company’s implication that the absence of these chemicals in its products make them superior to other cookware.
“GreenPan’s marketing of its GreenPan Products as superior simply because they do not contain compounds that other cookware does not contain is false and/or misleading,” the complaint states.
The plaintiff claims she paid a premium price for GreenPan cookware based on the defendant’s allegedly false representations. She seeks to represent anyone who purchased GreenPan non-stick products in California within the past four years.